By Chuck Gallagher | Business Ethics Keynote Speaker & AI Speaker and Author
It Started with a Conversation That Wasn’t Meant for Me
It was the kind of hallway conversation you’re not meant to hear. I was early to a corporate ethics roundtable, walking past two executives in a quiet side corridor. One of them, tense and whispering, said, “They’re shifting everything through Malaysia now—no paper trail, no tariffs. DOJ’s not watching this stuff.”
I stopped mid-stride. Not because the logistics shocked me. But because the assumption did. That the Department of Justice wasn’t watching.
A week later, I read the May 2025 announcement from the DOJ. Turns out, they are watching. Very closely. And that “stuff” just became one of the top white-collar enforcement priorities—right behind healthcare and procurement fraud.
As a former executive who crossed ethical lines and paid the price, I know what it feels like to tell yourself it’s “just good business.” But tariff fraud? This is no longer just a customs compliance issue. This is fraud with handcuffs attached. And yet, in boardrooms and supply chain meetings, far too many leaders are sleepwalking into it.
It’s time we wake up.
The Ethical Blind Spot: When Global Sourcing Becomes a Moral Mirage
Here’s the thing about tariff fraud: it hides in plain sight.
It’s not flashy. It’s not a Ponzi scheme. It’s not some CFO cooking the books in a basement. No, tariff fraud lives in invoice adjustments, country-of-origin mislabels, re-routed containers, or the casual suggestion to “bundle” a few classifications to save on duties. It’s a fraud of normalization—done by people who’d never call themselves criminals.
But that’s what makes it dangerous.
According to the DOJ’s Criminal Division, tariff fraud is now a criminal priority because it “disrupts legitimate supply chains and puts law-abiding companies at a competitive disadvantage.” In plain terms: it punishes those who play by the rules, and it rewards deception. That’s not business strategy. That’s systemic cheating.
And the DOJ isn’t bluffing. They’ve stood up a dedicated unit—the Market Integrity and Major Frauds Unit (MIMF)—specifically tasked with investigating these cases. They’re working hand-in-hand with Customs and Border Protection, Homeland Security, and the Commerce Department. They’re building indictments right now. Not hypothetical ones. Real ones.
This is the new frontier of white-collar enforcement. And it’s loaded with ethical landmines.
From Paperwork to Prison: The Leadership Risk No One Wants to Admit
Let’s get real. Most CEOs and CFOs aren’t waking up thinking, “How can we commit tariff fraud today?”
But that’s exactly the problem.
This kind of fraud happens by omission, not commission. It’s overlooked in the chase for margin. It’s buried under the spreadsheet logic of, “Well, our competitors are doing it.” It’s hidden behind third-party brokers, logistics firms, or shell companies in intermediary countries.
But guess what? The DOJ doesn’t care if you outsourced the mistake. They care that you benefited from it.
When I speak to executive teams, I often say: “Your silence isn’t innocent if your profits come from deception.”
Now, with this DOJ shift, silence may also come with subpoenas.
Ask yourself:
- Do you really know how your goods are being classified?
- Do you trust the declared country of origin on every shipment?
- Are you auditing your trade practices with the same rigor you apply to anti-bribery or FCPA?
- Or are you assuming—like that executive in the hallway—that nobody’s watching?
Because they are. And whistleblowers are coming forward. The DOJ’s whistleblower program incentivizes insiders to expose tariff fraud under the False Claims Act. And they’re backed by real money—often millions in recovered damages.
If you think “it won’t be us,” you’re wrong. It already is.
Strategic Action for Leaders Who Don’t Want Headlines
Here’s what I’d tell any boardroom I walk into:
1. Elevate Trade Compliance to Executive Risk
Tariff fraud is no longer the domain of logistics or mid-level compliance. It belongs in the C-suite. If you’re not reviewing customs and trade as a material risk, you’re exposed.
2. Audit Your Supply Chain With a Fraud Lens
Go beyond basic paperwork. Look for red flags like frequent reclassification, unusual transshipment routes, or repeated changes in declared value. These aren’t quirks—they’re signals.
3. Invest in Training That Teaches Ethical Context, Not Just Technical Rules
Knowing the Harmonized Tariff Schedule isn’t enough. Your teams need to understand why tariff fraud is unethical—and the ripple effects it creates.
4. Encourage Voluntary Disclosure Before It’s Too Late
The DOJ has made it clear: voluntary self-disclosure can reduce or eliminate criminal exposure. Waiting until you’re under investigation is not a strategy—it’s a sentence.
5. Shift the Cultural Narrative
If your internal language glorifies “creative sourcing” or “regulatory optimization” without scrutiny, you’ve already lost the plot. Ethical cultures don’t just follow the law—they lead with integrity.
The Human Bottom Line: Why This Isn’t Just About Trade
I served time in federal prison. Not because I didn’t know better—but because I chose not to act when it counted. I thought I could game the system and get away with it.
That’s the lie every white-collar criminal tells themselves: “This isn’t real crime. I’m not hurting anyone.”
But tariff fraud hurts people. It robs governments of lawful revenue. It disadvantages honest businesses. And it teaches the next generation of leaders that cheating is just another business tactic.
If you think ethics is soft, consider this: the DOJ just made it a felony.
So here’s my challenge to every executive, general counsel, and board chair reading this: don’t wait for a subpoena to rediscover your integrity.
Be the leader who chose transparency when silence was easier. Be the company that exposed the flaw instead of exploiting it.
Because in this new enforcement environment, you won’t just be asked what you did.
You’ll be judged by what you tolerated.
As always, we welcome your comments and are happy to respond. Feel free to share your thoughts below.
